"The universe is made of stories, not of atoms"

Archive for noviembre, 2010


Language as instrumental to the abuse of power and mind control in Animal Farm

Introduction

The most effective form of communication in society is speech, that is language. Language serves many functions, which include informative, entertaining and persuasive. In a political context it involves attracting attention and controlling listeners. The purpose of this paper is to analyze some features in Animal Farm that are of characteristics of the language of politics, portraying language as an instrument for attracting attention and controlling listeners.

It is also important when talking about George Orwell related to politics, to be familiarize with the events that marked his life and which made him reject any kind of totalitarian society:

George Orwell was educated in prestigious English schools with an atmosphere of constant taunting and endless competition for scholarship where he developed a contempt for any type of authority. He enlisted in the Indian Imperial Police when he was twenty years old, so during five years he witnessed imperialism rejecting it. In addition to that, when in 1936 the Spanish Civil War broke out, he joined the Republican side taking part into the conflict. During this period he saw the perversion of language through propaganda used as an instrument of war and mind control. It was specially during this war, and because of the conflict between Troskists and Stalinists, that George Orwell moved away from his early ideals.

Unlike many British socialists in the1930s and1940s, Orwell was not enamored of the Soviet Union and its policies, nor did he consider the Soviet Union a positive representation of the possibilities of socialist society. He could not turn a blind eye to the cruelties and hypocrisies of Soviet Communist Party, which had overturned the semifeudal system of the tsars only to replace it with the dictatorial reign of Joseph Stalin. Orwell became a sharp critic of both capitalism and communism, and is remembered chiefly as an advocate of freedom and a committed opponent of communist oppression.

Please, for a further study on George Orwell’s life and the historical context of Animal Farm before continuing reading the paper, click on the links:

_________________________________________

(table of contents)<<PREVIOUS – NEXT>> (overall view of Animal Farm)

Bibliography_ 1st paper_ Shakespeare

_Jhonston, Ian. Critical Approaches to Shakespeare: Some Initial Observations [on-line]. May 1999, November 2001 [ref. November 2010]. Available in World Wide Web:

< http://records.viu.ca/~johnstoi/eng366/approaches.htm >

_Mabillard, Amanda. Shakespeare’s Audience: The Groundlings [on-line]. Shakespeare Online. 20 Aug. 2000. [ref. November 2010]. Available in World Wide Web:

< http://www.shakespeare-online.com/essays/shakespeareaudience.html >

_Mabillard, Amanda. Entertainment in Elizabethan England [on-line]. Shakespeare Online. 20 Aug. 2000. [ref. November 2010]. Available in World Wide Web:

< http://www.shakespeare-online.com/faq/entertainment.html>

_McMillan, Eric. The Greatest Authors of all Time: William Shakespeare [on-line]. 2002-2003 [ref. October 2010]. Available in World Wide Web:

< http://www.editoreric.com/greatlit/authors/Shakespeare.html >

_Encyclopaedia Britannica. Guide to Shakespeare [on-line]. [ref. October 2010]. Available in World Wide Web:

< http://www.britannica.com/shakespeare >

_Wikipedia. William Shakespeare [on-line]. [ref. October 2010]. Available in World Wide Web:

< http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Shakespeare >

_Wikipedia. Elizabethan Era [on-line]. [ref. October 2010]. Available in World Wide Web:

< http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elizabethan_era >

_Wikipedia. The Taming of the Shrew [on-line]. [ref. October 2010]. Available in World Wide Web:

< http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Taming_of_the_Shrew >

_Gray, Terry A. The Taming of the Shrew. 25 April 1998. [ref. October 2010]. Available in World Wide Web:

<http://shakespeare.palomar.edu/lambtales/LTSHREW.HTM>

_Gardner, Patrick and Phillips, Brian. SparkNote on The Taming of the Shrew. 22 March 2007. [ref. October 2010]. Available in World Wide Web:

<http://www.sparknotes.com/shakespeare/shrew/characters.html>

Bibliography, URL’s _ first paper_ literatura inglesa y discurso politico

C.D. Merriman. “Geworge Orwell”. The Literature Network [on-line]. 2006 [ref. October 2010]. Available in World Wide Web: < http://www.online-literature.com/orwell/ >

Kerr, Douglas. «Orwell’s BBC Broadcasts: Colonial Discourse and the Rhetoric of Propaganda» [on-line].  Textual Practice, Volume 16, No. 3.  Charles’ George Orwell Links. December 2002 [ref. October 2010]. Available in World Wide Web:  < http://www.netcharles.com/orwell/articles/bbc-colonial-discourse.htm >

Pearce, Robert. «Orwell Now» [on-line]. History Today. Charles’ George Orwell Links. October 1997 [ref. October 2010]. Available in World Wide Web:< http://www.netcharles.com/orwell/ctc/docs/orwlnow.htm >

Wikipedia. «George Orwell» [on-line]. [ref. October 2010]. Available in World Wide Web:  < http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Orwell >

Wikipedia. «Animal Farm» [on-line]. [ref. October 2010]. Available in World Wide Web:  < http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animal_Farm >

SparkNotes Editors. “SparkNote on Animal Farm.” SparkNotes LLC. 2007 [ref. October 2010] Available in World Wide Web: < http://www.sparknotes.com/lit/animalfarm/ >

____________________________

BACK TO ABSTRACT

«Animal Farm» historical context

The theme of Animal Farm is not difficult to understand. Orwell intended to criticize, in an allegorical way, the totalitarian communist regime he saw in Russia. Though he agreed with many Marxist principles, Orwell was unable to accept the communist interpretation of socialism because he saw many similarities between the communist governments and the previous czarist regimes in old Russia. Communism, he thought, was inherently hypocritical.

So, in order to understand better the events described by George Orwell in his famous novel Animal Farm, it is important to know the revolution that took place during the first half of the 20th Century in Russia that destroyed the  Tsarist autocracy and led to the creation of the Soviet Union, paying special attention to its political system  that was characterized by the superior role of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (CPSU) which in fact became the only party permitted by Constitution.

Due to the complexity of the events, here  we are going to focus on the Soviet history under Communist Party rule, beginning with the October Revolution of 1917 and how it is related to the system established in Animal Farm, but I recommend you to visit the links provided below for further information and a better understanding of the allegorical meaning of the novel:

  • BBC documentary:  An analysis of Animal Farm as a representation of the corruption of the revolution by its leaders and of the rise and fall of Stalinism.

George Orwell «Animal Farm»_ historical context.

  • Documentary dealing with the Russian Revolution:

Part 1 (Duration : 09:38)

Part 2 (Duration : 09:25)

Part 3 (Duration : 09:49)

  • Original reports from The Times:

Russian Revolution 1917

  • Wikipedia’s article about the Russian Revolution:

Russian_Revolution_(1917)

_________________________________________________________

Russian society in the early twentieth century was bipolar: a tiny minority controlled most of the country’s wealth, while the vast majority of the country’s inhabitants were impoverished and oppressed peasants. Communism arose in Russia when the nation’s workers and peasants, assisted by a class of concerned intellectuals known as the intelligentsia, rebelled against and overwhelmed the wealthy and powerful class of capitalists and aristocrats. They hoped to establish a socialist utopia based on the principles of the German economic and political philosopher Karl Marx.

In February 1917, Tsar Nicholas II, the monarch of Russia, abdicated and the socialist Alexander Kerensky became premier. At the end of October, Kerensky was ousted, and Vladimir Lenin, the architect of the Russian Revolution, became chief commissar. Almost immediately, as wars raged on virtually every Russian front, Lenin’s chief allies began jockeying for power in the newly formed state; the most influential included Joseph Stalin, Leon Trotsky, Gregory Zinoviev, and Lev Kamenev. Trotsky and Stalin emerged as the most likely heirs to Lenin’s vast power. Trotsky was a popular and charismatic leader, famous for his impassioned speeches, while  Stalin preferred to consolidate his power behind the scenes. After Lenin’s death in 1924, Stalin orchestrated an alliance against Trotsky that included himself, Zinoviev, and Kaminev. In the following years, Stalin succeeded in becoming the unquestioned dictator of the Soviet Union and had Trotsky expelled first from Moscow, then from the Communist Party, and finally from Russia altogether in 1936. Trotsky fled to Mexico, where he was assassinated on Stalin’s orders in 1940.

In 1934, Stalin’s ally Serge Kirov was assassinated in Leningrad, prompting Stalin to commence his infamous purges of the Communist Party. Holding “show trials”. Stalin had his opponents officially denounced as participants in Trotskyist or anti-Stalinist conspiracies and therefore as “enemies of the people,” an appellation that guaranteed their immediate execution. As the Soviet government’s economic planning faltered and failed, Russia suffered under a surge of violence, fear, and starvation. Stalin used his former opponent as a tool to placate the wretched populace. Trotsky became a common national enemy and thus a source of negative unity. He was a frightening specter used to conjure horrifying eventualities, in comparison with which the current misery paled. Additionally, by associating his enemies with Trotsky’s name, Stalin could ensure their immediate and automatic elimination from the Communist Party.

These and many other developments in Soviet history before 1945 have direct parallels in Animal Farm: Napoleon ousts Snowball from the farm and, after the windmill collapses, uses Snowball in his purges just as Stalin used Trotsky. Similarly, Napoleon becomes a dictator, while Snowball is never heard from again. Orwell was inspired to write Animal Farm in part by his experiences in a Trotskyist group during the Spanish Civil War, and Snowball certainly receives a more sympathetic portrayal than Napoleon. Every animal character in the novel is based on one «protagonist» of the Russian Revolution:

But though Animal Farm was written as an attack on a specific government, its general themes of oppression, suffering, and injustice have far broader application and modern readers have come to see Orwell’s book as a powerful attack on any political, rhetorical, or military power that seeks to control human beings unjustly.

Meet George Orwell

Eric Arthur Blair, better known by his pen name George Orwell and as the author of Animal Farm and 1984, was born in 1903 in Bengal, region of Eastern India, which was part of the British Empire. He was son of Richard Walnesley Blair, who worked in the Opium Department of Indian Civil Service, and Ida Mabel Blair. Due to certain gradual impoverishment of his family, he always described it as «lower-upper-middle class».

Only one year after his birth, his mother moved to England with him and his two sisters. George Orwell did not see his father again until 1912, when his father joined them.

George Orwell was educated in England in prestigious boarding schools as a scholarship student, but he felt oppressed by the strict control this schools exercised over their students, in fact he wrote an essay, Such, Such Were the Joys, based on his experiences there, describing the social challenges he endured as a scholarship student among England’s wealthy elite. This essay was published 2 years after his death. It was possibly a source of his initial resentment towards authority.

After graduating at Eton secondary school in 1921, and because of the economic situation of his family, which could not afford college, Eric Arthur Blair joined the Indian Imperial Police, in Burma.  There  he was working until 1927, when due to a Dengue fever he contracted but specially to his increasing disillusionment with the reality of British imperialism in India, which made him suspicious of the established class system in English society,  he decided to resign from the Indian Imperial Police and to become a writer. Works he wrote influenced by this period of his life are the novel Burmese Days (1934) and the essays A Hanging (1931) and Shooting an Elephant (1936).

Once back in England, he became devoted to the problems of class and government power, and inspired by Jack London’s 1903 book The People of the Abyss, Orwell bought ragged clothes from a second-hand store and went to live among the very poor in London. In the spring of 1928, he moved to Paris, where the bohemian lifestyle offered an attraction for many aspiring writers. After reemerging, he published a book about these experiences, entitled Down and Out in Paris and London (1933), and The Spike, his first published essay.

As a young man, Orwell became a socialist, speaking openly against the excesses of governments, and using the pseudonym, George Orwell, he began writing articles for magazines. In 1936 Orwell was commissioned by Victor Gollancz to produce a documentary account of unemployment in the north of England for his Left Book Club. The Road to Wigan Pier established Orwell as one of Britain’s leading writers and marked a high point in literary journalism.

On 9 June 1936 Orwell married Eileen O’Shaughnessy and In 1944 they would adopt a son, Richard Horatio. When Civil War broke out in Spain in 1936, Blair and his wife both wanted to fight for the Spanish government against Francisco Franco’s Nationalist uprising. He traveled to Spain to report on the Spanish  War, where he witnessed firsthand the nightmarish atrocities committed by fascist political regimes. While on the front at Huesca in Aragon Blair was shot in the throat by “a Fascist sniper”. Orwell stepped into a complex political situation in Catalonia. The Republican government was supported by a number of factions with conflicting aims, including the Workers’ Party of Marxist Unification (POUM — Partido Obrero de Unificación Marxista), the anarcho-syndicalist Confederación Nacional del Trabajo and the Unified Socialist Party of Catalonia (a wing of the Spanish Communist Party, which was backed by Sovietarms and aid). The ILP was linked to the anti-Stalinist Spanish Trotskyist ‘Partido Obrero de Unificación Marxista’ or POUM,  so Orwell joined the POUM. When the communists partly gained control and tried to purge the POUM, many of Blair’s friends were arrested, shot, or disappeared. He and Eileen barely escaped to England in June 1937. His autobiographical Homage to Catalonia is written in the first person, few months after the events. In the book Orwell attempted to expose the propaganda disseminated by newspapers in Britain. This included attacks on both the right-wing press and the Daily Worker, a paper controlled by theCommunist Party.

Unlike many British socialists in the1930s and1940s, Orwell was not enamored of the Soviet Union and its policies, nor did he consider the Soviet Union a positive representation of the possibilities of socialist society. He could not turn a blind eye to the cruelties and hypocrisies of Soviet Communist Party, which had overturned the semifeudal system of the tsars only to replace it with the dictatorial reign of Joseph Stalin. Orwell became a sharp critic of both capitalism and communism, and is remembered chiefly as an advocate of freedom and a committed opponent of communist oppression.  The rise to power of dictators such as Adolf Hitler in Germany and Joseph Stalin in the Soviet Union inspired Orwell’s mounting hatred of totalitarianism and political authority. Orwell devoted his energy to writing novels that were politically charged, his two greatest anti-totalitarian novels—Animal Farm (1945) and 1984 (1949)—form the basis of his reputation.

Back in England, Orwell set to freelance writing  for such publications as New English Weekly, The Tribune and New Statesman, writing essays about different authors like Charles Dickens, William Butler Yeats or Arthur Koestler.

On the outbreak of World War II Orwell was declared unfit for any kind of military service by the Medical Board in June, but soon afterwards found an opportunity to become involved in war activities by joining the Home Guard. In August 1941, Orwell finally obtained «war work» when he was taken on full time by the BBC’s Eastern Service. He supervised cultural broadcasts to India to counter propaganda from Nazi Germany designed to undermine Imperial links. This was Orwell’s first experience of the rigid conformity of life in an office. However it gave him an opportunity to create cultural programmes with contributions from T. S. Eliot, Dylan Thomas, E. M. Forster, Ahmed Ali, Mulk Raj Anand, and William Empson among others. By February 1945 David Astor had invited Orwell to become a war correspondent for the Observer. During wartime, Orwell and his wife adopted a son, but his wife died shortly afterwards, on 29 March 1945. Also during this time, Orwell completed Animal Farm. The book met with immediate and far-reaching public success.

Orwell continued to write for periodicals while completing his second renowned novel,1984. He remarried, in 1949, to Sonia Brownell.

Orwell, who was prone to illness, had his career and his life cut short when he died of tuberculosis on January 21, 1950. His friend, David Astor, arranged for Orwell’s burial in a small county churchyard. Orwell is buried under his birth name. He left a strong literary and political legacy, being one of those artists who influenced not only the literary universe, but also the real world in which he lived. As he wrote in his essay Politics and the English Language: «In our age there is no such thing as ‘keeping out of politics.’ All issues are political issues, and politics itself is a mass of lies, evasions, folly, hatred and schizophrenia.»

_______________________________

If you are interested in a more detailed biography you can visit the links below for more information:

You can also find interesting pictures and videos about George Orwell at this blog:

________________________________

<<BACK to table of contents – NEXT : Animal Farm historical context>>

George Orwell: images

Picture of George Orwell which appears in an old acreditation for the BNUJ. 1933

George Orwell's signature.

NEXT>>

Katherine: an attempt of breaking social rules

Before reading the paper, please read The Taming of the Shrew or, at least, a summary of the plot.

Katherine: an attempt of breaking social rules

In The Taming of the Shrew, Shakespeare creates a troubling comedy that explores Elizabethan issues of gender or gender roles: that is, the socially accepted definitions of appropriate male and female behavior.

On the surface, the play appears to confirm a very traditional Elizabethan view that men should dominate women and that women should submit to male authority. All of the characters except Katherina agree throughout the play that her initial rebellious, self-assertive, «shrewish» behavior is not acceptable. Analyzing the different characters throughout the play, we can find a reflection of how Elizabethan society was:

  • Baptista: We can see in this character how men thought of their wives and daughter as their property, expecting from them to be docile and obedient. He is one of the wealthiest men in Padua, and his daughters, Bianca and Katherina, become the prey of many suitors due to the substantial dowries he can offer. His absentmindedness increases when Kate shows her obstinate nature. Thus, at the opening of the play, he is already desperate to find her a suitor, having decided that she must marry before Bianca does.
  • Bianca: The younger daughter of Baptista. The “lovely” Bianca can be considered the opposite of her sister, Kate, at the beginning of the play. This character is the stereotype of the perfect women during Shakespeare’s time: she is soft-spoken, sweet, and unassuming. Because of her large dowry and her mild behavior, several men vie for her hand. It is important to remember at this point that Marriage was seen as the desirable state for both men and women, and single women were sometimes looked upon with suspicion.
  • Petruchio: Petruchio represents the man who conceives marriage as a business, although he will take care of his wife. Petruchio is a gentleman from Verona. Loud, boisterous, eccentric, quick-witted, and frequently drunk, he has come to Padua “to wive and thrive.” He wishes for nothing more than a woman with an enormous dowry, and he finds Kate to be the perfect fit.

Signor Hortensio, ‘twixt such friends as we

Few words suffice; and therefore, if thou know

One rich enough to be Petruchio’s wife—

As wealth is burden of my wooing dance—

Be she as foul as was Florentius’ love,

As old as Sibyl, and as curst and shrewd

As Socrates’ Xanthippe or a worse,

She moves me not—or not removes at least

Affection’s edge in me, were she as rough

As are the swelling Adriatic seas.

I come to wive it wealthily in Padua;

If wealthily, then happily in Padua.

(I.ii.62–73)

Disregarding everyone who warns him of her shrewishness, apart from his prospective wife’s wealth, Petruchio says that he does not care about any of her other qualities. This speech exemplifies Petruchio’s brash, robust manner of speaking. He is blatantly honest about his materialism and selfishness, and he also straightforwardly acknowledges the economic aspect of marriage—something that everyone in the play is keenly aware of but which only Petruchio discusses so frankly and openly and with so little concern for romantic love. In spite of this, we can see a strong sexual attraction between Katherina and Petruchio as well as a growing comradeship. Moreover, although Petruchio seeks to control Katherina, at the end he appears to admire and value her spirit.

  • Lucentio: Just as Bianca is Katherine’s opposite, the intrepid, lovesick Lucentio serves as a foil for Petruchio throughout the play. Lucentio reflects the sort of idyllic, poetical view of love that Petruchio’s pragmatism dismisses: Lucentio is struck by love for Bianca at first sight, says that he will die if he cannot win her heart, and subsequently puts into motion a romantic and fanciful plan to do so. Whereas love in the play is often mitigated by economic and social concerns, Lucentio is swept up in a vision of courtly love that does not include the practical considerations of men like Petruchio. Throughout much of the play, then, Lucentio and Bianca’s relationship appears to be refreshing and pure in comparison to the relationship between Petruchio and Katherine. Petruchio’s decision to marry is based on his self-proclaimed desire to win a fortune, while Lucentio’s is based on romantic love.
  • Katherine: she is a character that does not fit in the stereotype of the Elizabethan woman. Katherine is the “shrew” of the play’s title, the daughter of Baptista Minola, with whom she lives in Padua. Widely reputed throughout Padua to be a shrew, Kate is foul-tempered and sharp-tongued at the start of the play. She constantly insults and degrades the men around her, particularly anyone who tries to marry her. Her hostility toward suitors particularly distresses her father. Though most of the play’s characters simply believe Katherine to be inherently ill-tempered, it is certainly plausible to think that her unpleasant behavior stems from unhappiness because she feels out of place in her society. Throughout the play Shakespeare made  a big change in the way Katherine seems to conceive marriage and the role of men and women, she does not resist her suitor Petruchio forever, though, and she eventually subjugates herself to him, despite her previous repudiation of marriage.

Due to Katherine’s intelligence and independence, she is unwilling to play the role of the maiden daughter, the “perfect woman”. She clearly abhors society’s expectations that she obey her father and show grace and courtesy toward her suitors. At the same time, however, Katherine must see that given the rigidity of her social situation, her only hope to find a secure and happy place in the world lies in finding a husband. These inherently conflicting impulses may lead to her misery and poor temper. A vicious circle ensues: the angrier she becomes, the less likely it seems she will be able to adapt to her prescribed social role; the more alienated she becomes socially, the more her anger grows.

Thanks to this character, Shakespeare was able to present in front of the audience the problems of a society where gender roles were so rigid, Where women with desires of independence, who are capable of taking care of themselves and who are sure about being equal to men, were treated as a wild animal which needs to be tamed. The play is, in fact, a comedy about an assertive woman coping with how she is expected to act in the society of the late sixteenth century and of how one must obey the unwritten rules of a society to be accepted in it.

We can understand the taming of Katherine and the play’s attitude toward gender roles in different ways:

  • Although the play ends with her outwardly conforming to the norms of society, this is in action only, not in mind. Although she assumes the role of the obedient wife, inwardly she still retains her assertiveness. I this sense, Katherina’s final speech should be read ironically, with the implication that she will pretend to defer to Petruchio in public while ruling the household in private.

Thy husband is thy lord, thy life, thy keeper,

Thy head, thy sovereign . . .

Such duty as the subject owes the prince,

Even such a woman oweth to her husband,

And when she is froward, peevish, sullen, sour,

And not obedient to his honest will,

What is she but a foul contending rebel

And graceless traitor to her loving lord?

I am ashamed that women are so simple [foolish]

To offer war where they should kneel for peace,

Or seek for rule, supremacy, and sway,

When they are bound to serve, love, and obey.

(5.2.148-66 / Katherine’s final speech)

This adaptation to to her social role as a wife must be attractive to Katherine on some level, since even if she dislikes the role of wife, playing it at least means she can command respect and consideration from others rather than suffer the universal revulsion she receives as a shrew.

  • The play ultimately accepts and reinforces male dominance of women as it shows how a woman can only be happy acting as she is expected to do and being obedient to his father and husband, reason why Katherine changes his mind about marriage, etc.
  • While accepting male dominance the play emphasizes the need for mutual affection, cooperation, and partnership in marriage.
  • The play ultimately undermines male dominance of women by showing this dominance to be artificial and illogical.

In my opinion, and taking into account the way in which Shakespeare presented the play before the audience, I think that Shakespeare’s intention was the first one of the options presented above, and I do so because of the different devices used by Shakespeare in order to distance the audience from what happens in the play.One must also take into account the attitudes of sixteenth century England and the fact that the play is a comedy and is not meant to be taken seriously.

The play-within-a-play structure emphasizes to the audience that what they are about to see is a performance, not reality, but someone’s interpretation of reality in a satirized way, exaggerating the features of characters such as Katherine or Petruchio. In this way, the audience didn’t feel scandalized in front of a woman who rejects, at least at the beginning, her social role and the superiority of men.

In addition to that, Shakespeare chose a setting for the play far away from where the audience was from, Italy. Doing so he achieved to stress that what they were watching was not reality but a performance, so they did not have such problems about social and gender roles.

Confusion between appearance and reality is a principal source of humor in The Taming of the Shrew, giving place to grotesque situations. In the Induction, Sly is misled by carefully orchestrated appearances into believing that he is really a wealthy nobleman rather than a poor tinker. The subplot likewise depends on the confusion of appearance and reality as various characters practice elaborate deceptions. Hortensio pretends to be the music teacher Litio. Lucentio poses as the schoolmaster Cambio. He and Bianca use Latin lessons as a cover for their courtship, and they deceive her father by eloping on the eve of her planned betrothal to another man. Lucentio’s servant, Tranio, pretends to be his master and persuades an elderly scholar to pose as his master’s father. Following with the device of false realities that Shakespeare set in place so early in the play, it would seem more logical that Katherine would simply be acting the part of ‘the obedient wife’ in order to be accepted in the society in which she lives.  Katherine can ‘play a part’ very well and can even enjoy doing it. In fact, It is difficult to believe that a character as vibrant and strong-willed as Katherine is changed/”tamed” so easily.

________________________

<<Social role of women during the Elizabethan era — Conclusion>>