"The universe is made of stories, not of atoms"

Katherine: an attempt of breaking social rules


Before reading the paper, please read The Taming of the Shrew or, at least, a summary of the plot.

Katherine: an attempt of breaking social rules

In The Taming of the Shrew, Shakespeare creates a troubling comedy that explores Elizabethan issues of gender or gender roles: that is, the socially accepted definitions of appropriate male and female behavior.

On the surface, the play appears to confirm a very traditional Elizabethan view that men should dominate women and that women should submit to male authority. All of the characters except Katherina agree throughout the play that her initial rebellious, self-assertive, «shrewish» behavior is not acceptable. Analyzing the different characters throughout the play, we can find a reflection of how Elizabethan society was:

  • Baptista: We can see in this character how men thought of their wives and daughter as their property, expecting from them to be docile and obedient. He is one of the wealthiest men in Padua, and his daughters, Bianca and Katherina, become the prey of many suitors due to the substantial dowries he can offer. His absentmindedness increases when Kate shows her obstinate nature. Thus, at the opening of the play, he is already desperate to find her a suitor, having decided that she must marry before Bianca does.
  • Bianca: The younger daughter of Baptista. The “lovely” Bianca can be considered the opposite of her sister, Kate, at the beginning of the play. This character is the stereotype of the perfect women during Shakespeare’s time: she is soft-spoken, sweet, and unassuming. Because of her large dowry and her mild behavior, several men vie for her hand. It is important to remember at this point that Marriage was seen as the desirable state for both men and women, and single women were sometimes looked upon with suspicion.
  • Petruchio: Petruchio represents the man who conceives marriage as a business, although he will take care of his wife. Petruchio is a gentleman from Verona. Loud, boisterous, eccentric, quick-witted, and frequently drunk, he has come to Padua “to wive and thrive.” He wishes for nothing more than a woman with an enormous dowry, and he finds Kate to be the perfect fit.

Signor Hortensio, ‘twixt such friends as we

Few words suffice; and therefore, if thou know

One rich enough to be Petruchio’s wife—

As wealth is burden of my wooing dance—

Be she as foul as was Florentius’ love,

As old as Sibyl, and as curst and shrewd

As Socrates’ Xanthippe or a worse,

She moves me not—or not removes at least

Affection’s edge in me, were she as rough

As are the swelling Adriatic seas.

I come to wive it wealthily in Padua;

If wealthily, then happily in Padua.

(I.ii.62–73)

Disregarding everyone who warns him of her shrewishness, apart from his prospective wife’s wealth, Petruchio says that he does not care about any of her other qualities. This speech exemplifies Petruchio’s brash, robust manner of speaking. He is blatantly honest about his materialism and selfishness, and he also straightforwardly acknowledges the economic aspect of marriage—something that everyone in the play is keenly aware of but which only Petruchio discusses so frankly and openly and with so little concern for romantic love. In spite of this, we can see a strong sexual attraction between Katherina and Petruchio as well as a growing comradeship. Moreover, although Petruchio seeks to control Katherina, at the end he appears to admire and value her spirit.

  • Lucentio: Just as Bianca is Katherine’s opposite, the intrepid, lovesick Lucentio serves as a foil for Petruchio throughout the play. Lucentio reflects the sort of idyllic, poetical view of love that Petruchio’s pragmatism dismisses: Lucentio is struck by love for Bianca at first sight, says that he will die if he cannot win her heart, and subsequently puts into motion a romantic and fanciful plan to do so. Whereas love in the play is often mitigated by economic and social concerns, Lucentio is swept up in a vision of courtly love that does not include the practical considerations of men like Petruchio. Throughout much of the play, then, Lucentio and Bianca’s relationship appears to be refreshing and pure in comparison to the relationship between Petruchio and Katherine. Petruchio’s decision to marry is based on his self-proclaimed desire to win a fortune, while Lucentio’s is based on romantic love.
  • Katherine: she is a character that does not fit in the stereotype of the Elizabethan woman. Katherine is the “shrew” of the play’s title, the daughter of Baptista Minola, with whom she lives in Padua. Widely reputed throughout Padua to be a shrew, Kate is foul-tempered and sharp-tongued at the start of the play. She constantly insults and degrades the men around her, particularly anyone who tries to marry her. Her hostility toward suitors particularly distresses her father. Though most of the play’s characters simply believe Katherine to be inherently ill-tempered, it is certainly plausible to think that her unpleasant behavior stems from unhappiness because she feels out of place in her society. Throughout the play Shakespeare made  a big change in the way Katherine seems to conceive marriage and the role of men and women, she does not resist her suitor Petruchio forever, though, and she eventually subjugates herself to him, despite her previous repudiation of marriage.

Due to Katherine’s intelligence and independence, she is unwilling to play the role of the maiden daughter, the “perfect woman”. She clearly abhors society’s expectations that she obey her father and show grace and courtesy toward her suitors. At the same time, however, Katherine must see that given the rigidity of her social situation, her only hope to find a secure and happy place in the world lies in finding a husband. These inherently conflicting impulses may lead to her misery and poor temper. A vicious circle ensues: the angrier she becomes, the less likely it seems she will be able to adapt to her prescribed social role; the more alienated she becomes socially, the more her anger grows.

Thanks to this character, Shakespeare was able to present in front of the audience the problems of a society where gender roles were so rigid, Where women with desires of independence, who are capable of taking care of themselves and who are sure about being equal to men, were treated as a wild animal which needs to be tamed. The play is, in fact, a comedy about an assertive woman coping with how she is expected to act in the society of the late sixteenth century and of how one must obey the unwritten rules of a society to be accepted in it.

We can understand the taming of Katherine and the play’s attitude toward gender roles in different ways:

  • Although the play ends with her outwardly conforming to the norms of society, this is in action only, not in mind. Although she assumes the role of the obedient wife, inwardly she still retains her assertiveness. I this sense, Katherina’s final speech should be read ironically, with the implication that she will pretend to defer to Petruchio in public while ruling the household in private.

Thy husband is thy lord, thy life, thy keeper,

Thy head, thy sovereign . . .

Such duty as the subject owes the prince,

Even such a woman oweth to her husband,

And when she is froward, peevish, sullen, sour,

And not obedient to his honest will,

What is she but a foul contending rebel

And graceless traitor to her loving lord?

I am ashamed that women are so simple [foolish]

To offer war where they should kneel for peace,

Or seek for rule, supremacy, and sway,

When they are bound to serve, love, and obey.

(5.2.148-66 / Katherine’s final speech)

This adaptation to to her social role as a wife must be attractive to Katherine on some level, since even if she dislikes the role of wife, playing it at least means she can command respect and consideration from others rather than suffer the universal revulsion she receives as a shrew.

  • The play ultimately accepts and reinforces male dominance of women as it shows how a woman can only be happy acting as she is expected to do and being obedient to his father and husband, reason why Katherine changes his mind about marriage, etc.
  • While accepting male dominance the play emphasizes the need for mutual affection, cooperation, and partnership in marriage.
  • The play ultimately undermines male dominance of women by showing this dominance to be artificial and illogical.

In my opinion, and taking into account the way in which Shakespeare presented the play before the audience, I think that Shakespeare’s intention was the first one of the options presented above, and I do so because of the different devices used by Shakespeare in order to distance the audience from what happens in the play.One must also take into account the attitudes of sixteenth century England and the fact that the play is a comedy and is not meant to be taken seriously.

The play-within-a-play structure emphasizes to the audience that what they are about to see is a performance, not reality, but someone’s interpretation of reality in a satirized way, exaggerating the features of characters such as Katherine or Petruchio. In this way, the audience didn’t feel scandalized in front of a woman who rejects, at least at the beginning, her social role and the superiority of men.

In addition to that, Shakespeare chose a setting for the play far away from where the audience was from, Italy. Doing so he achieved to stress that what they were watching was not reality but a performance, so they did not have such problems about social and gender roles.

Confusion between appearance and reality is a principal source of humor in The Taming of the Shrew, giving place to grotesque situations. In the Induction, Sly is misled by carefully orchestrated appearances into believing that he is really a wealthy nobleman rather than a poor tinker. The subplot likewise depends on the confusion of appearance and reality as various characters practice elaborate deceptions. Hortensio pretends to be the music teacher Litio. Lucentio poses as the schoolmaster Cambio. He and Bianca use Latin lessons as a cover for their courtship, and they deceive her father by eloping on the eve of her planned betrothal to another man. Lucentio’s servant, Tranio, pretends to be his master and persuades an elderly scholar to pose as his master’s father. Following with the device of false realities that Shakespeare set in place so early in the play, it would seem more logical that Katherine would simply be acting the part of ‘the obedient wife’ in order to be accepted in the society in which she lives.  Katherine can ‘play a part’ very well and can even enjoy doing it. In fact, It is difficult to believe that a character as vibrant and strong-willed as Katherine is changed/”tamed” so easily.

________________________

<<Social role of women during the Elizabethan era — Conclusion>>

Elizabethan society


Social role of women during the Elizabethan era


The Taming of the Shrew is one of Shakespeare’s earliest comedies, where the author focuses on courtship and marriage and devotes a great deal of attention to married life after the wedding. Because of this, we are going to focus our study on social role of women during the Elizabethan era, and how Shakespeare presents to the audience in this play a woman who does not fits in it.

  1. 1. Role of women during the period

In Shakespeare’s days, the stereotypical images of both men and women were very rigid. The Elizabethans had very clear expectations of men and women, and in general men were expected to be the breadwinners and women to be housewives and mothers. Elizabethan society was patriarchal, and men were thought to be somehow superior to women, who were regarded as “the weaker sex”, not only physically but also emotionally. In this sense, it was believed that women always needed someone to look after them: their husband, their father, brother or another male relative.

A husband instructs his obedient family. From Internet Shakespeare Edition.

1.2. Education:

Regarding education, although many women in this period were educated, they were educated at home by private tutors because women were not allowed to go to school or to university and, in addition to that, they should be educated separately from men. Elizabeth being on the throne also encouraged noble men to educate their daughters, as they did not want them to look dim in the presence of their very intelligent and highly educated queen. It wasn’t until the end of the 19th century that some universities were beginning to accept a few wealthy women to study degree courses. However, they were still educated separately from the men. They only learnt how to manage a household and the duties of a housewife. This kind of “domestic education” would let them find a husband, which was of vital importance for most women. In fact, single Elizabethan women were often thought to be strange people by those surrounding them. Being unable to stand the pressure by their neighbors, most single women ended up in convents. (Alchin, “Elizabethan Women”)

1.3. Marriage:

One common belief about the Renaissance is that children, especially girls, married young. In some noble houses marriages were indeed contracted at a young age, for reasons of property and family alliance, but in fact the average age of marriage was quite old–in the middle twenties. (Michael Best, Shakespeare’s Life and Times)

Man was considered to be the head of a marriage, and he had the legal right to punish his wife. The law regarded a married couple as one person, and the husband was that one. A dominant woman was unnatural, a symptom of disorder. Men thought of theirs wives and daughters as their property, and so did the law:

  • Until 1882 women had to give up their property to their husbands when their married him.
  • Until 1891 husbands were allowed by law to beat their wives “with a stick “no thicker than a man’s thumbs” and to lock them in a room if they wished.
  • Except in extremely rare cases, a woman could not obtain a divorce and, until 1891, if she ran away from an intolerable marriage the police could capture and return her, and her husband could imprison her.

The wife’s subordinate status was based on religious conceptions of hierarchy. The Book of Common Prayer directs the priest to read, to the newly married pair, a homily which quotes the passage of St. Paul (Ephesians, 5: 22-5):

“Ye women, submit your selves unto your own husbands, as unto the Lord. For the husband is the wife’s head, even as Christ is the head of the Church, and he is the saviour of the whole body. Therefore as the Church in congregation is subject unto Christ: so likewise let the wives be in subjection unto their own husbands in all things.”

In The Taming of the Shrew, Kate, already tamed, gives a “lesson” to the other women on the «natural» domestic order. The imagery makes clear the correspondence between the family and the nation:

Thy husband is thy lord, thy life, thy keeper,

Thy head, thy sovereign . . .

Such duty as the subject owes the prince,

Even such a woman oweth to her husband,

And when she is froward, peevish, sullen, sour,

And not obedient to his honest will,

What is she but a foul contending rebel

And graceless traitor to her loving lord?

I am ashamed that women are so simple [foolish]

To offer war where they should kneel for peace,

Or seek for rule, supremacy, and sway,

When they are bound to serve, love, and obey.

(5.2.148-66)

This excerpt is a perfect example of how women were expected to be during this period. John Fitzherbert in A Book of Husbandry (1525), also says:

“Our English housewife must be of chaste thought, stout courage, patient, untired, watchful, diligent, witty, pleasant, constant in friendship, full of good neighbourhood, wise in discourse, but not frequent therein, sharp and quick of speech, but not bitter or talkative, secret in her affairs, comfortable in her counsels, and generally skilful in all the worthy knowledges which do belong to her vocation.”

Women who perhaps suffered most in this period were, ironically, those like the Queen who did not wish to marry. Tudor society did not have many avenues open to single women and, following the Reformation, those avenues were even less. Before, women were able to become nuns and look forward to a rewarding life in convents, perhaps be a Mother Superior one day.  But with the Reformation, the convents were closed. Wealthy single women (heiresses of property) could look forward to being mistress of their estates and wield the power in the community this would bring, but for poor women, the only long-term “career” really open to them was domestic service. It was not surprising, therefore, that most women married. Marriage was seen as the desirable state for both men and women, and single women were sometimes looked upon with suspicion.

1.4. Women’s “place”:

As is the case of education, women were not allowed to enter the professions as law, medicine, etc., “their place” was home, they could work in domestic service as cooks or maids and of course, these were jobs for the lower class women.

1.5. Other aspects related to women during the Elizabethan era:

Women, regardless of social position, were not allowed to vote, but it isn’t strange if we take into account that only men of a certain social position were allowed to vote. Neither could women inherit their father’s titles. All titles would pass from father to son or brother to brother, depending on the circumstances. The only exception was, of course, the crown. This allowed Mary, and then Elizabeth, to reign. Writing literature was allowed to them but only if the subject was suitable for women: mainly translations or religious works. Acting on the public stage or write for the public stage was, completely forbidden; it was considered dishonorable for women (women did not appear on the stage in England until the 17th century). In Shakespeare’s plays, the roles of women were often played by young boys.

_______________________________

<<table of contents – – Katherine: an attempt of breaking social rules>>

Animal Farm videos


Part 1 (Duration: 08:41)

Part 2 (Duration: 02:57)

Part 3 (Duration 03:16)

Animal farm_1955 film (Duration: 01:11:58)

Animal Farm (trailer)_1999 film (Duration 02:05)

Read Animal Farm


Read George Orwell’s Animal Farm free online!


Read the novel (public domain) :

chapter by chapter

(eBooks@Adelaide)

or the

full text (Portable Document Format)




George Orwell videos


Links to some interesting videos on George Orwell’s life:

  • George Orwell: A life in Pictures is an Emmy award winning 2003 BBC Television docudrama telling the life story of the British author:

George Orwell: A life in Pictures

(Duration: 01:28:19)


  • Documentary that covers Orwell’s life and background and ends with an overview of his work. Written, produced and directed by Malcolm Hossick:

George Orwell part 1 (Duration: 06:06)

George Orwell part 2 (Duration: 06:28)

George Orwell part 3 (Duration: 05:53)

George Orwell part 4 (Duration: 05:00)

George Orwell part 5 (Duration: 05:40)

George Orwell part 6 (Duration: 05:40)


Meet William Shakespeare


In the links provided below you can find biographical information and videos related to William Shakespeare:

You can also watch a video-documentary where professor Jonathan Bate speaks about Shakespeare life. I think it is really interesting and well explained:

Literature


Literature: Literary productions as a whole; the body of writings produced in a particular country or period, or in the world in general. Now also in a more restricted sense, applied to writing which has claim to consideration on the ground of beauty of form or emotional effect. (OED)

…BUT…

What do they say?

«The thing that teases the mind over and over for years, and at last gets itself put down rightly on paper — whether little or great, it belongs to Literature.»

Sarah Orne Jewett

«Literature is my Utopia. Here I am not disfranchised. No barrier of the senses shuts me out from the sweet, gracious discourse of my book-friends. They talk to me without embarrassment or awkwardness.»

Hellen keller

«Literature, the most seductive, the most deceiving, the most dangerous of professions»

John Morley

«The universe is made of stories, not of atoms»

Muriel Rukeyser

«The books that the world calls immoral are the books that show the world its own shame»

«Literature always anticipates life. It does not copy it, but moulds it to its purpose. The nineteenth century, as we know it, is largely an invention of Balzac.»

Oscar Wilde

«A book must be the ax for the frozen sea within us»

Franz Kafka

«Literature is strewn with the wreckage of those who have minded beyond reason the opinion of others.»

«Literature adds to reality, it does not simply describe it. It enriches the necessary competencies that daily life requires and provides; and in this respect, it irrigates the deserts that our lives have already become.»



«Literature is where I go to explore the highest and lowest places in human society and in the human spirit, where I hope to find not absolute truth but the truth of the tale, of the imagination and of the heart.»